An independent panel constituted in terms of Clauses 20.3 and 21.3 of the NHA Constitution and consisting of Messrs K Miedema, J Vermaak and C Gordon was convened on 7 January 2026 to consider a Merit Rating Appeal lodged by Trainer Mr André Nel against CUTIE PATOOTIE’s published adjusted merit rating of 84 following her win on 24 December 2025 at Hollywoodbets Kenilworth Racecourse, OPEN MAIDEN (F & M), Race 3. 

The Appeal Panel was of the opinion that the line horse which was utilised, VIXEN’S WAR, was appropriate under the circumstances. 

The Appeal was dismissed, and Trainer Nel’s deposit is refunded. 

Enquiries: 

Michael Shackleton

Legal Executive